Their Hot Fudge Sundae isn’t just hot fudge on ice cream—it’s a perfect ratio of warm and cold, sweet and slightly bitter, smooth and creamy. It’s the Goldilocks of sundaes—just right in every way.

Hidden in Broken Bow’s vacation paradise is a treasure chest of frozen delights guarded by a giant cowboy statue. Locals will tell you the banana splits are worth driving across state lines for, and ...