Thick but not earthy, sweet but not cloying, Skippy screams peanut butter and jelly sandwich. $4 for 16.3-ounce jar at target.com Related: The Difference Between Natural and Conventional Peanut ...

After Dwyane Wade said that he and LeBron James are "like peanut butter and jelly," Smucker's and Jif responded -- the brands are strong. Richard Jefferson gave us all a close-up view of the jars.

By day three, some contestants chose to forgo the jelly, opting for a generous smear of peanut butter on a piece of bread instead. Each peanut butter jar was wrapped in paper to conceal the name ...