When Puella Magi Madoka Magica aired in 2011 ... but shocking. She is the witch Charlotte, and her violent murder of Mami Tomoe is one of the starkest tonal shifts in any anime.

Editor’s Note: There are some Homura Akemi Puella Magi Madoka Magica spoilers in the Magia ... It begins with Homura inside of a Witch’s Labyrinth. She asserts, “I can do it on my own ...

Take the first and most memorable death: Mami's beheading at the hands (well, mouth) of Charlotte. While most viewers had already guessed Madoka Magica was hiding some darker secrets, this ...