In the shadow of towering pines, where the air smells of forest and pastry, Beckie’s Café in Prospect, Oregon has been performing small miracles with butter, flour, and seasonal fruit for generations.

In a world of flashy food trends and Instagram-worthy plates, this unassuming Amish Country eatery has been quietly serving up some of the most soul-satisfying food in the Buckeye State. The modest ...