Sarah Michelle Gellar turned down a chance to return for I Know What You Did Last Summer 's legacy sequel, according to the film's director. While the Buffy star's husband Freddie Prinze Jr is reprising his role as Ray Bronson and Jennifer Love Hewitt is back as Julie James, there's no surprise revival for Gellar's Helen Shivers.

Actor Sarah Michelle Gellar sits down with TODAY’s Jenna Bush Hager and guest co-host Tiffany Haddish to talk about the upcoming reboots for two of her ’90s cult-classic movies, “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” and “I Know What You Did Last Summer.

No, horror fans, we don’t know if we’ll see the next round of fun and games in the Ready or Not universe on the 2025 movie schedule. However, what we do know about Ready or Not 2 has just changed pretty drastically.