Things get a little more complicated when comparing the two stores' custom cakes. Sam's Club's $19.98 custom half-sheet cake easily trumps the price of Costco's, which rings up at $26.99.

So you can imagine how upset I was when I learned that Sam’s Club took Ina Garten’s copycat coconut cake off its shelves. Sure, Costco’s version is good, but it doesn’t quite compare to ...

So you can imagine how upset I was when I learned that Sam’s Club took Ina Garten’s copycat coconut cake off its shelves. Sure, Costco’s version is good, but it doesn’t quite compare to the one I’ve ...